Saatva vs Brooklyn Bedding
When shopping for a new mattress, Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding stand out as two popular hybrid mattress options. But with different constructions, materials, policies, and more, it can be tricky to determine which is better suited for you. This in-depth Saatva vs Brooklyn Bedding comparison breaks down the key differences between the two top mattress brands to help you make an informed decision.
Pricing and Value
Saatva mattresses are known for their luxury designs and materials, coming at a higher price point than the more budget-friendly Brooklyn Bedding.
Saatva Pricing
Saatva’s flagship Saatva Classic mattress starts at $1,095 for a twin, ranging up to $2,095 for a split king. The higher-end Loom & Leaf memory foam mattress starts at $1,099, while the natural latex Zenhaven mattress is priced from $1,899 to $3,898. Saatva mattresses are considered a solid value given their luxury construction and materials.
Brooklyn Bedding Pricing
Meanwhile, Brooklyn Bedding’s most popular Signature Hybrid model starts at just $699 for a twin and ranges up to $1,249 for a queen. The higher-end Brooklyn Aurora hybrid with advanced cooling starts at $1,249. Brooklyn Bedding is known for its affordable pricing, making it a great budget choice. The brand also regularly offers sales and promos.
So while Saatva commands around a $600+ premium for a queen size, Brooklyn Bedding wins when it comes to price and deals. However, Saatva delivers a more luxurious, high-end mattress.
Construction and Materials
When it comes to how Saatva vs Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are actually built, there are considerable differences that impact comfort, support, and more.
Saatva Construction
The Saatva Classic combines dual layers of coil-on-coil innerspring construction with foams and a Euro pillow top cover. This creates excellent bounce, edge support, and breathability. The base support unit features recycled steel Bonnell coils topped by pocketed microcoils in the lumbar region. Memory foam then provides pressure relief before a plush Euro pillow top enhances comfort.
Brooklyn Bedding Construction
Brooklyn Bedding’s Signature Hybrid pairs dense, durable pocketed coils with several layers of proprietary foams: TitanFlex polyfoam, Energex foam, and Ascension layered latex. This allows close contouring to relieve pressure while the coils provide bounce and reinforcement along the perimeter. The mattress has solid edge support but less airflow than Saatva’s spring design.
In terms of quality, Saatva offers thicker overall profiles while Brooklyn Bedding uses more advanced, innovative foam layers. But Saatva’s dual coil support core makes it the winner for those wanting true hybrid resilience.
Firmness and Feel
With different constructions come different mattress feels between Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding. This also means they suit varying sleeping positions and weights.
Saatva Firmness
A key advantage of Saatva is offering three firmness options in one mattress: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. This accommodates nearly all sleepers regardless of weight and preferences. The foam Euro pillow top allows close contouring and pressure relief where needed. Underneath, the buoyant coil layers provide plenty of support for spinal alignment.
Brooklyn Bedding Firmness
Similarly, Brooklyn Bedding allows you to choose from three firmness levels: Soft, Medium, and Firm. The softer option contains deeper, more contouring memory foams while the Firmest uses denser, more responsive materials. Overall, Brooklyn Bedding has more of a “floating” feel compared to Saatva’s stable support. However, it still suits most sleep positions.
For the most customization of feel and firmness, Saatva is the winner. But Brooklyn Bedding still offers broad appeal.
Motion Isolation
For couples, minimizing motion transfer across the mattress surface allows for undisturbed sleep when your partner moves. Here’s how Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding compare at limiting disturbances.
Saatva Motion Isolation
Due to its thick foam layers, Saatva provides very good motion isolation. The memory foam in particular helps absorb movement before it travels widely. Couples should experience minimal sleep disturbances like tossing and turning.
Brooklyn Bedding Motion Isolation
With multiple foam comfort layers, Brooklyn Bedding also effectively reduces motion transfer. The proprietary foams isolate rather than transfer motion. So couples can expect a peaceful night’s sleep without disturbances.
Both Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding effectively isolate motion for couples. But Saatva may have a slight edge thanks to its thicker profile and memory foam.
Durability and Longevity
Considering these mattresses represent a significant investment, you’ll want assurance they will provide many years of comfortable sleep. Here is how Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding compare in terms of durability and owner experiences.
Saatva Durability
With its thick dual coil layers and reinforced edges, Saatva earns excellent marks for durability and longevity. The sturdy support system prevents sagging and indentations even years later. Many customers report their Saatva still feels like new after 5+ years. And Saatva offers one of the best warranties available.
Brooklyn Bedding Durability
The dense foams and durable coils of Brooklyn Bedding mattresses also achieve impressive durability and lifespan for the price. They resist body impressions and breakdown very well over time. Owners praise both the Signature and Aurora models for retaining their shape and performance.
Both Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding make exceptionally durable mattresses based on owner experiences. Saatva may last slightly longer thanks to its resilient coils. But Brooklyn Bedding offers more years of use than expected given its affordable pricing.
Edge Support
Proper edge support allows you to sleep all the way to the side of the mattress without feeling like you’ll roll off. It also makes getting in and out of bed easier plus maximizes the usable surface area for couples.
Saatva Edge Support
With two layers of reinforced coils, Saatva earns stellar marks for edge support. The sturdy perimeter prevents sagging when sitting on the sides. Sleepers can utilize the entire mattress surface without feeling unstable or tipping over the edges.
Brooklyn Bedding Edge Support
Brooklyn Bedding also reinforces the edges of its coils to prevent excessive sinkage and roll-off feelings along the perimeter. However, some report wishing it had slightly better edge support, especially the softer models. But it still performs better than most beds.
If exceptional edge support is a priority, then Saatva is the winner. But Brooklyn Bedding still performs reasonably well in this category given its foam and coil construction.
Temperature Regulation
Sleeping cool and comfortable is key for a restful night. Excess heat buildup can cause tossing, turning, and night sweats. Here is how Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding mattresses compare at temperature regulation and airflow.
Saatva Temperature Regulation
With its breathable coil layers and cotton cover, the Saatva prevents excessive heat retention and allows impressive airflow. The innerspring design is naturally more airy and ventilated than foam. So no matter your sleep position or room temperature, this mattress sleeps exceptionally cool and comfortable.
Brooklyn Bedding Temperature Regulation
While not as breezy as Saatva, Brooklyn Bedding still rates well for temperature neutrality. The foam layers don’t retain as much heat as expected while the coil core allows some airflow. Unless you really sleep hot, the Signature and Aurora prevent excessive sweating and heat buildup.
For the absolute coolest sleep, Saatva is the winner. But Brooklyn Bedding still rates very good for minimizing heat and keeping comfortable resting temperatures.
Trial Period and Returns
Buying a mattress online often comes with the assurance of a risk-free trial period during which you can test out the bed. Here is the fine print on Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding’s sleep trials and return policies.
Saatva Sleep Trial
Saatva offers an impressive 365-night sleep trial for all purchases. This gives you plenty of time to decide if it’s the right fit for your sleep needs. If you do return your Saatva, there is a $99 transportation fee. Saatva will arrange pickup and donation of the used mattress.
Brooklyn Bedding Sleep Trial
Brooklyn Bedding also provides 120 nights to try your mattress at home. If you return your bed within this window, there are no fees whatsoever. Simply initiate a return through customer service and Brooklyn Bedding arranges pickup of the mattress.
For the longest trial period, Saatva wins. But Brooklyn Bedding makes returns simpler without extra charges or logistics to handle.
Conclusion and Recommendations
So in this Saatva vs Brooklyn Bedding comparison, which hybrid mattress reigns supreme?
For shoppers wanting a true luxury mattress with thicker profiles, more customization, and advanced cooling, Saatva is the winner. Its quality craftsmanship and materials justify the higher price tag. Just expect to pay extra delivery and return fees.
However, Brooklyn Bedding makes an outstanding choice for budget buyers wanting an affordable yet high-quality hybrid mattress. It provides close contouring pressure relief and solid edge support at a much lower cost. And returns are simpler with no extra fees.
Ultimately, choosing between Saatva and Brooklyn Bedding comes down to your budget, preferred feel and firmness, and importance of policies like trial periods. But either way, you get an exceptional hybrid mattress made to provide years of healthy, supportive rest.
