Saatva vs Allswell Mattress

The mattress market is filled with options, ranging from budget-friendly brands to luxury models with impressive features. Two popular picks are Saatva and Allswell – but they cater to very different shoppers. This comprehensive mattress comparison reviews everything from price to policies, so you can decide which best suits your sleep style and budget.

Pricing and Value

When it comes to cost, Saatva and Allswell are on opposite ends of the spectrum.

Saatva Mattresses

Saatva beds are premium models made with high-end materials like organic cotton, memory foam, and recycled steel coils. Their flagship innerspring mattress starts at $935 for a twin and ranges up to $2,195 for a split king. The Saatva Latex Hybrid is pricier, from $1,299 to $2,695. So while well-constructed, these beds come with luxury price tags.

Allswell Mattresses

Allswell takes a completely different approach with budget-friendly pricing. The Allswell Mattress begins at just $375 for a twin and maxes out at $855 for a California king. Their Luxe Hybrid model runs slightly higher, from $465 to $1,045. But even the most expensive Allswell bed costs thousands less than the least expensive Saatva.Clearly, Allswell wins when it comes to affordability and saving money. But Saatva offers exceptional quality and materials for the premium investment.

Comfort and Feel

From the materials inside to how they feel for different sleeping positions, Saatva and Allswell mattresses differ significantly in terms of comfort.

Saatva Comfort Layers

The Saatva mattress features a Euro pillow top with plush comfort foam and a touch of organic cotton for breathability. Underneath sits a layer of memory foam lumbar support, followed by a pocketed coil unit with foam encasement. The dual steel coil system provides reinforced stability. Available with three firmness levels, Saatva allows you to customize the balance of contour and support.The Saatva Latex Hybrid uses natural, sustainable Talalay latex in the comfort system. This responsive foam adjusts to your body for pressure relief while resisting impressions over time. Zoned coils add targeted reinforcement so you never sink too deep.

Allswell Comfort Design

The original Allswell Mattress combines a quilted top panel with 1 inch of memory foam for a classic feel. Pocketed coils sit below to limit motion transfer while reinforcing the bed. With a medium firm feel, this design suits all sleeping positions. But it lacks the customization of Saatva.Moving up, the Allswell Luxe has a Euro top with gel-infused memory foam for a close contour. An inch of transition foam prevents you from bottoming out on the pocketed coils. The medium feel hugs without trapping heat.When comparing comfort, Saatva takes the lead for personalization while Allswell offers great value.

Durability and Quality

The quality of materials and construction impacts how long your mattress will provide restful sleep before needing to be replaced.

Saatva Mattress Construction

Saatva manufactures all their mattresses in the United States using eco-friendly practices. They only use certified organic cotton, recycled steel coils, and foams that meet CertiPUR-US® standards for durability. With robust components like a double coil system and reinforced perimeter, Saatva beds achieve an average lifespan of 7-10 years or more – much longer than the average innerspring.

Allswell Mattress Make

Although Allswell imports their mattresses from Asia, they oversee production and test materials carefully to control for quality assurance. The brand meets CertiPUR-US® and OEKO-TEX® safety standards as well. With foams at 1.8 to 2 pounds density and a reinforced quantum edge, Allswell mattresses can last 6-8 years with proper care. While not as robust as Saatva, this is impressive given the affordable prices.For those wanting a long-term investment, Saatva offers exceptional quality and durability. But Allswell makes great beds considering the budget price tag.

Customer Service

The buying experience and post-purchase support are also important factors when choosing a new mattress online.

Saatva’s White Glove Delivery

Saatva sets themselves apart with luxury white glove delivery included free with all purchases. Your new bed will arrive with expert setup in your room of choice and removal of an old mattress if needed. Their sleep specialists also provide guidance over the phone whenever you need it. Plus Saatva offers free mattress alterations during the trial if firmness ends up incorrect. All aspects make buying from Saatva truly stress-free.

Allswell’s Streamlined Service

Since Allswell focuses on budget beds, they cannot offer the same white glove treatment as Saatva. All mattress purchases ship free via FedEx Ground, conveniently compressed in boxes you move into the bedroom yourself. If any issues come up, you can get in touch with Allswell’s customer experience team by email, phone, text, or chat. So while more limited, their service meets basic expectations.For a pampered buying experience, Saatva is the clear winner. But Allswell still offers decent customer communication channels.

Sleep Trials and Returns

One perk of buying a bed online is getting an extended at-home trial period. This gives you several months to decide if the mattress suits your comfort needs before fully committing. If it doesn’t work out, hassle-free returns are important as well.

Saatva’s 365 Night Trial

Saatva stands out by offering an entire year-long sleep trial, so you can test your mattress across all seasons. If you decide it’s not the best fit within the first 365 nights, you can return the bed for a $99 transportation fee. Saatva will then arrange for donation or recycling of the used mattress. This trial is one of the longest in the industry.

Allswell’s 100 Night Trial

The sleep trial for Allswell mattresses clocks in at 100 nights instead. This matches policies from other budget online brands. If the bed doesn’t satisfy by night 100, Allswell arranges pickup and refunds the purchase price less shipping costs. One limitation is Allswell will not retrieve mattresses from Alaska or Hawaii, so trial periods are shorter in those states.For risk-free testing, Saatva again proves exceptional with their 1-year home trial. But Allswell still gives you several months to break in the mattress.

Saatva vs Allswell Verdict

Now that we’ve compared every aspect from price to trial periods, who should buy from Saatva versus Allswell?

Saatva’s Luxury Mattresses Suit:

• Shoppers wanting high-end materials like organic cotton and latex
• Those seeking tailored comfort with plush to firm options
• People who value exceptional service like white glove delivery
• Anyone wanting a long-term mattress investment

Yes, Saatva costs far more than the average bed-in-a-box. But you get great return on investment thanks to the quality craftsmanship and sleep trial length.

Allswell’s Budget Beds Suit:

• Budget shoppers unable to spend over $1,000 on a mattress
• College students and young adults furnishing their first apartment
• Guest rooms, vacation homes, and other spare spaces
• Anyone wanting a temporary mattress for a few years

For the affordable prices, Allswell mattresses punch above their weight in terms of materials and performance. So they make great cheap beds for short-term needs.

The Final Recommendation

At the end of the day, choosing between Saatva and Allswell comes down to your budget and priorities.Allswell offers impressive value, using decent foams and coils that outlast traditional budget brands. If you want the best mattress possible for under $500, definitely consider the Allswell Mattress or Luxe Hybrid.But for shoppers who can invest more upfront, Saatva hits a sweet spot between affordable and luxury. The eco-friendly designs provide personalized support for years to come. And Saatva’s white glove delivery ensures exceptional service from purchase to setup.So determine whether price or high-end quality matters more. Both Saatva and Allswell make great mattresses specializing in different areas. We hope this detailed comparison helps you select your dream bed for restful nights!